12 Common HR Stereotypes vs. What It’s Really Like
There are many HR stereotypes and myths that give HR departments a bad rap within their organizations and also might prevent people from wanting to build a career in HR. We’re going to have a look at some common HR stereotypes and contrast them with the reality.
Why stereotyping exists
It’s human nature to make generalized associations from our surroundings and cultural influences. We form these simplified perceptions of reality from our own observations and experiences, from what we see depicted in media or entertainment, or from what we hear others say.
Stereotyping even occurs unconsciously when the mind tries to process and organize the vast amount of information it takes in by putting it into categories. In other words, stereotyping is a type of bias or a cognitive shortcut.
There are numerous types of stereotypes, which are typically based on:
- sex and/or gender identity (Boys like to play with trucks and girls like to play with dolls)
- race, ethnicity, nationality (Germans are the most hardworking nation in Europe)
- age (All older people are bad with technology)
- socioeconomic status (Low-income people are less competent)
- groups of individuals (Software developers are introverted geeks, HR employees are people persons – more on that below)
- and more.
Common HR stereotypes and HR myths
Many professions bring certain connotations to mind. Particular traits may be presumed when we think of a politician, accountant, doctor, or truck driver, just to name a few. However, stereotyping is a generalization, so it can be an inaccurate interpretation of the truth about any particular grouping.
Related (free) resource ahead! Continue reading below ↓
51 HR Metrics cheat sheet
Data-driven HR starts by implementing relevant HR metrics. Download the FREE cheat sheet with 51 HR Metrics
Here are some of the common misconceptions about HR, where they might come from, and what is the reality or ideal scenario:
1. HR has little responsibility beyond administration and bureaucracy
The stereotype: HR is seen as the department responsible for paperwork and simple administrative tasks. (Employees, as well as the organizational leadership, may not be aware of all HR’s tactical work.)
The reality: Documentation, record-keeping, compliance, and oversight of policies and procedures are crucial functions of Human Resources, so there are many administrative tasks to be done. However, HR’s main responsibilities are strategic.
The overall purpose of HR is to figure out how to get the best out of employees to help the organization achieve its goals. HR should play the role of a business partner and be relied on for designing and implementing changes and courses of action needed to move the company forward. Ultimately, this positively impacts the bottom line.
2. HR operates in isolation
The stereotype: HR is autonomous and doesn’t need to collaborate with other departments. (Because some of HR’s work has a classified nature, it has certain boundaries with other departments to maintain confidentiality.)
The reality: HR can’t and doesn’t work entirely alone. In fact, HR must collaborate with every department. They closely work with managers and leaders to share information and support organizational growth through HR strategy.
3. HR lacks business and data knowledge
The stereotype: HR probably doesn’t understand how their company makes money, let alone how to make data-driven decisions. (This comes from a limited understanding of everything HR does, both from employees’ and management sides, and because HR’s focus is employees, not whatever product or service the organization offers.)
HR professionals need to thoroughly understand their organization and its industry. For instance, you can’t successfully recruit the right talent for a position if you don’t have some idea about the role, the industry, and the market.
What’s more, HR has also become increasingly data-driven in analyzing problems within organizations. HR professionals must understand the data and identify interventions based on analytics and various metrics. An example of this would be calculating the employee turnover rate, understanding what the results imply, and then taking action to decrease turnover.
4. HR doesn’t really listen to or take action on employee complaints
The stereotype: HR just processes employees’ complaints and does nothing about them. (Sometimes HR doesn’t have available staff to focus on complaints, or they simply haven’t been handled well.)
The reality: HR should be concerned with all employee complaints, even the minor ones that stem from miscommunication. HR must conduct documented investigations to work towards remedying the problems. This involves active listening to understand an employee’s side of the story so they feel heard. In addition, it is crucial to follow up to let employees know what steps have been taken and where the investigation stands.
5. HR only acts in the company’s interest
The stereotype: The HR department only cares about protecting the company. (Since HR is responsible for communicating and implementing company policies, employees can see it as biased toward management.)
The reality: Capable HR professionals work with staff to resolve issues and ensure they’re treated well, while at the same time balancing the organization’s goals. They can adhere to company policies while still advocating for the workforce.
HR should regard employees as internal consultants who provide valuable insight that can be shared with management. When HR is able to empathize and see the big picture of any issue, it serves the interests of both parties.
6. You don’t need any special skills to go into HR
The stereotype: Anyone can do HR. They’re usually people who didn’t get a job in sales or marketing. (HR has not always been a field that people initially planned to go into or pursued as a course of study, so many HR professionals have evolved into their roles.)
The reality: To succeed as an HR professional, you need to have various specific skills, such as business acumen, data literacy, and specialization in one or more HR functions. You also must be competent in people advocacy, interpersonal communication, and time management. This field requires you to be constantly working on developing these abilities and also continuing to gain new competencies.
7. HR just spoils all the fun
The stereotype: HR is the “fun police” and punishes people for making innocent jokes and pranks. (This comes from the fact that HR is in charge of enforcing employee conduct rules and is typically involved when someone has to be disciplined or terminated.)
The reality: HR professionals do not want to micromanage employees’ behaviors or interactions, but they do play an essential role in creating company culture. HR is tasked with helping to nurture an inclusive environment where all employees can feel safe, and the people in HR generally strongly believe in supporting this.
8. HR is all about hiring, reprimanding, and firing employees
The stereotype: HR’s main tasks are to hire, reprimand, and fire employees. (These are the HR roles that are the most obvious to employees, and little thought goes into what else is in its scope of responsibility.)
The reality: There’s so much more to HR than that, as it oversees the entire employee lifecycle. HR must be behind the strategy for how staff is sourced, hired, and managed efficiently while supporting the company’s mission and goals to lead it to success.
9. All HR cares about are policies and procedures
The stereotype: HR is always focused on policies and doing things by the book to just complete their checklists. (Employees know that policies come from HR, but they may not understand their significance.)
The reality: HR needs to ensure compliance by applying clear-cut procedures. Employment relationships must adhere to various laws and regulations, and HR is responsible for comprehending and navigating them. HR makes sure that organizations fulfill their legal and ethical obligations to protect employees and the business. But again, this is just one of the many responsibilities of HR.
10. There’s no creativity involved in HR
The stereotype: HR is very uninspired and boring since it’s all about administration and policies. (Again, this comes from a view of HR that is limited to what it produces externally, not what it does behind the scenes.)
The reality: Fostering creativity in business has become all the more important in recent years because of continuous change happening in the economy, global competition, and the expansion of flexible work options.
HR managers often need to be creative and think outside of the box to support innovation and come up with improvements and solutions to problems. For example, this would be redesigning policies to fit the hybrid work environment or innovating an organization’s benefits offering to reflect the pandemic and post-pandemic reality.
11. HR professionals are all people persons
The stereotype: HR professionals love people and want to help them, and that’s why they’re in HR. (The assumption is that a business-minded person wouldn’t see HR as a good fit because it’s all about taking care of people.)
The reality: It’s actually more important for them to be able to see the big picture and to be strategic about building a productive workplace. HR is about organizing people within processes to achieve results. A desire to work with people is necessary, but you must also be up for the challenge of deciding how to best develop and structure them to solve business problems.
12. Technology is going to replace HR
The stereotype: HR automation is going strong, which means that HR will soon be replaced by technology. (Employees who have digital access to self-service HR support may think everything HR does can be automated.)
The reality: Technology is undoubtedly changing HR but not replacing it. Routine HR processes are continually being redefined and streamlined, so they take less time to complete. This frees up HR to focus on more strategic tasks and use all the automation-generated data for better problem-solving and decision-making.
Why it is important to dispel these stereotypes and how to do it
There can be some element of truth in most stereotypes. Still, a limited view or misconception of reality is inaccurate and can be harmful when it causes the wrong response.
HR’s full potential within an organization can be hindered by these myths when they produce the following results:
- Preventing employees from trusting HR and getting their problems solved.
- Precluding leadership and the organization from benefiting from all that HR can bring to the table.
- Deterring talented people from pursuing a career in HR.
Here are a few ideas of how to counter the HR stereotypes and their negative effects. These can be used by an individual HR professional or as an overall HR strategy for your organization:
Improve communication about the role of HR to your employees by:
- Increasing genuine interactions with employees and one-on-one conversations that encourage a more co-worker-type relationship.
- Seeking out ongoing, honest feedback from employees and demonstrating that you understand what’s going on with them enough to act on their ideas or complaints.
- Ensuring employees have equal representation throughout the conflict resolution process.
- Offering a more complete picture of changes being made that affect employees. Give a brief background and explain what they will accomplish and why this is the right way.
Strengthen the relationship between HR and other departments by:
- Creating partnerships by dedicating HR representatives to work with each team and get a grasp of what they’re doing.
- Aligning HR initiatives with individual departments by connecting with managers on a regular basis to maintain clear communication. This will help employees experience HR as consistent throughout the organization.
Use data to demonstrate your impact to the leadership by:
- Knowing what type of data leadership requires and producing related reports as often as needed.
- Explaining how HR’s role in effective human capital management improves retention and employee engagement statistics for better productivity.
Exercise your current abilities and continue upskilling yourself to create more influence by:
- Communicating clearly in every interaction and showing enthusiasm for HR initiatives.
- Being flexible and compassionate toward employees and management so people know they are heard.
- Striving for impartiality to find the right balance between representing the company and being a voice for employees.
- Using creativity to come up with new ideas and resolutions to problems.
- Developing new or enhanced skills in data literacy, communication, leadership, or other areas to expand what you have to offer, for example, by gaining an HR certification.
The HR profession involves a wide range of responsibilities that open it up to misconceptions. Those who work in it know it’s a tough job, and stereotypes held by multiple stakeholders don’t make it any easier. However, don’t let these outdated beliefs cause you to doubt HR’s value or discourage your efforts to make your company a productive and inclusive workplace.
You can take the initiative in trying to redefine people’s mindset about HR and be proactive in dispelling the common HR stereotypes. Let them see the valuable support HR offers and how key it is in strengthening the bridge between individuals and the organization’s mission.